|
Although water
is the oldest rehabilitation modality, few rehab professionals understand the magnitude,
variety and rapidity of its healing effects. Yet much research over the centuries validates
these effects, and recent research adds further understanding: The aquatic environment
produces physiologic changes that help remove metabolic waste, improve cardiac function,
lower blood pressure and assist the body in tissue healing. Through understanding the
principles of aquatic physics and applying them to human physiology, clinicians can design
aquatic programs to help a broad range of people achieve fitness and function. This article
creates a foundation for understanding those profound physiologic changes.
IMMEDIATELY AFTER a person is immersed, water begins to exert pressure on the body.
Because the pressure exerted is greater than venous pressure, the blood is placed upward,
first into the thighs, then into the abdominal cavity vessels, and finally into the great
vessels of the chest cavity and into the heart. Venous return is enhanced by the shift of
blood from the periphery to the trunk vessels to the thorax to the heart. Central venous
pressure rises with immersion to the chest and increases until the body is completely immersed.
Cardiac volume increases by nearly one-third with immersion to the neck. Because the heart is
not static, it responds by increasing the force of contraction, an effect known as Starlings law.
Water-based exercise often has been said to be less effective than land
based exercise for
improving cardiovascular fitness, largely because the failure to achieve similar pulse rates.
Since the heart's ultimate purpose is to pump blood, its best measure of performance is the
amount of blood pumped per unit time. Called cardiac output, this is the product of the volume
of blood pumped with each contraction (stroke volume) times pulse rate per unit time. The heart
muscle must work harder during exercise to increase output by increasing rate than by increasing
stroke volume. Thus, as cardiovascular conditioning occurs, cardiac output increases are achieved
with greater stroke volumes per beat but smaller increases in heart rate. The pulse rate of the
conditioned athlete, for instance, is lower than that of an unfit individual for any given cardiac
output by approximately 5 L/min. Submersion to neck depth increases cardiac output 32 percent at rest.
Because of the increased stroke volume, a resting pulse of 86 bpm produces a cardiac output of 8.6 L/min.,
and is already producing cardiac exercise. Therefore, the claim that water exercise is not aerobically
efficient is faulty. In fact, it may be the ideal cardiovascular conditioning medium.
TWO RECENT STUDIES have validated aquatic environments in cardiovascular
rehabilitation following infarct and ischemic heart disease. Both investigators
took the bold step of actively rehabilitating patients with cardiac disease in
an aquatic environment. While water helps patients with diseased hearts, it
also helps those with joint disease. Studies have found that oxygen consumption (VO 2) is three times
greater at a given walking speed in water than on land. Thus, when one looks at the reverse effect of this
fact, only half to one-third of the speed is required to achieve the same metabolic intensity as on land.
This effect may help patients with joint disease since lower joint forces are present with slower speed.
Water is equally beneficial for patients with hypertension. When people are immersed to the neck, for
instance, systemic vascular resistance decreases by 30 percent, with peripheral venous tone diminishing by
30 percent. Total peripheral resistance lowers during the first hour of immersion and persists for a time
thereafter. This drop is related to temperature, with higher temperatures producing greater drops. This
decreases end-diastolic pressures and cardiac after load. While systolic pressures do increase with increasing
workload, they appear to be approximately 20 percent less in water than on land. Thus, water is a safe and
beneficial environment for patients who are hypertensive.
|
Like the circulatory system, the pulmonary system is
profoundly affected by immersing the body to the thorax. Part of the effect is
due to blood shifting into the chest cavity, and part is due to
compression of the chest wall. The combined effect alters pulmonary function, increases the work of
breathing and changes respiratory dynamics. In fact, expiratory reserve volumes decrease by 75 percent
at neck immersion, with vital capacity decreasing only slightly. About half of this reduction is due to
increased thoracic blood volume, and half is due to hydrostatic forces counteracting the inspiratory
musculature. The combined effects of these changes increases the total work of breathing by 60 percent.
Thus, for an athlete used to land-based exercise, water-based exercise is a significant workload challenge
to the respiratory apparatus. If water training time is sufficient, this challenge can improve the
respiratory system's efficiency. Water immersion positively affects the
musculoskeletal system as
well, particularly with vasoconstriction. On land for instance, sympathetic vasoconstriction tightens
the resistance vessels of the skeletal muscle to resist blood pooling. But water, immersion pressure
removes the biologic need for vasoconstriction, thus increasing muscle blood flow. In fact, resting
muscle blood flow increases by 225 percent during neck immersion." Aquatic immersion creates many
effects upon renal blood flow and the renal regulatory systems. For instance, the flow of blood to the
kidneys increases immediately upon immersion, which produces an increase urine and potassium excretion
(see chart). Sodium excretion also increases as a function of depth due to the shifting of circulating
central blood volume. MANY EFFECTS have been anecdotally noted about using aquatic environments for
health maintenance and restoration. Predominant among these are the relaxation effect of water, and
the effect it has on pain perception. A relaxation effect is produced by a central process not
understood and likely produced within the reticular activating system deep within the brain. Mood
state has been found to improve following land exercise but has not been as well studied in an aquatic
environment. Similarly, anxiety and depression are reduced following land exercise; research to test
these effects following aquatic exercise has not been done. Although some controversy exists about
the optimal training program for athletes who need joint off-loading during a recovery period, it is
known that aquatic exercise can indeed increase conditioning in that population. In fact, water running
equals land running in its effect upon maintaining VO 2 max when training intensities and frequencies are
matched." Similarly, when aquatic exercise is compared with land-based
equivalent exercise in its effect upon maximum gains in VO 2 in unfit
individuals, aquatic exercise achieves equivalent results; when water
temperature is low, the gains achieved are accompanied by lower heart rate
water-based exercise programs may be used to sustain or increase aerobic
conditioning in athletes who need joint off-loading. Nonetheless, aquatic exercise programs may restore fitness in patients
who are obese because of the protective effects against heavy joint loading. A program that starts in
water and moves to land as tolerance builds may be the most effective method of achieving conditioning
and weight loss.
This article and its
attached references provide a basis for clinical dialogue about the effects of water immersion.
Tremendous potential public health benefits can be achieved through programs targeted at the most
significant physiologic consequences of aging, hypertension, cardiovascular disease arthritis and other
joint pathology obesity and deconditioning. This truly is the time to get in the swim of things.
|